When I brought Birch home — a scrappy little mixed-breed pup with floppy ears and an underbite — I swore I’d do things differently than I did with Cooper. Cooper was my 13-year-old Lab who passed away from cancer two years ago, and one of my biggest regrets was not knowing more about what was lurking in his genetics. I knew he was a yellow Lab. That was it. No health risk data, no breed breakdown beyond the obvious.
So when Birch turned 8 weeks old, I ordered two DNA tests at the same time: Embark Dog DNA Test and Wisdom Panel Essential. I wanted to compare them head-to-head on the same dog. Here’s what I found.
Why I Decided to DNA Test Birch
After losing Cooper, I became obsessed with proactive health care. One of the things his oncologist mentioned — almost as an aside — was that certain breeds have higher genetic predispositions to specific cancers. Goldens and Labs are among them. If I’d known more about Cooper’s genetic health risks early on, would it have changed anything? Maybe not. But maybe I would have screened earlier. Maybe I would have caught something sooner.
With Birch, I’m not leaving that to chance. Dog DNA testing has come a long way in the past few years. Both Embark and Wisdom Panel are the two dominant players, and the internet is full of vague comparisons. I wanted actual, side-by-side data from the same dog.
The Testing Process
Both tests work the same way: swab the inside of your dog’s cheek, let the swab air dry, seal it up, and mail it in. Birch was cooperative for both — she seems to enjoy having things shoved in her mouth, which tracks. No blood draws, no vet visits. The hardest part was making sure she hadn’t eaten for an hour before swabbing, which anyone with a puppy knows is basically impossible.
Turnaround times:
- Embark: About 3–4 weeks
- Wisdom Panel: About 2–3 weeks
Wisdom Panel came back first. Embark took a little longer, but I’d read that’s normal because they’re doing more genetic analysis.
Breed Results: Both Got It Right (Mostly)
Birch turned out to be a mix of Australian Shepherd, Border Collie, and a dash of Labrador — which explains the herding-meets-chaos energy she brings to every morning. Both tests agreed on the core breeds. That was reassuring. Where they diverged was in the smaller percentages and in how they broke down the ancestry.
Embark was more specific about ancestral populations — it actually traces your dog’s lineage back multiple generations and can show you which great-grandparent contributed what. Wisdom Panel’s breed breakdown was solid but felt more like a pie chart and less like a family tree. For pure breed curiosity, both work. For deeper ancestry nerdery, Embark wins.
Health Screening: Where Embark Pulls Ahead
This is the big one. And it’s not close.
Embark screens for over 230 genetic health conditions. Wisdom Panel Essential screens for around 35. If you upgrade to Wisdom Panel Premium, you get more — around 200+ — but that costs more than the base kit.
For Birch, Embark found that she carries one copy of a MDR1 gene mutation (also called the ABCB1 gene), which affects how dogs metabolize certain drugs — particularly some common antiparasitic medications like ivermectin, used in many heartworm preventatives. This is a big deal. Some dogs with this mutation have had serious neurological reactions to medications their owners thought were routine.
Wisdom Panel, at the Essential tier I purchased, did not flag this. I don’t know if that’s because it wasn’t in their panel or because it showed differently — but the fact that Embark caught it and Wisdom didn’t was the deciding moment for me.
I immediately flagged this with Birch’s vet. She was grateful I knew. We adjusted our heartworm prevention protocol to use a medication that’s safe for MDR1-affected dogs. That one data point alone may have saved Birch from a serious medical event down the road.
Traits and Physical Characteristics
Both tests predict physical traits — coat type, body size, shedding level. For novelty, it’s fun. Embark predicted Birch would have a double coat and moderate shedding. Wisdom Panel said similar things. Neither prediction was dramatically wrong, though Birch’s shedding levels suggest she didn’t get the memo.
Wisdom Panel does have a “family finder” feature that lets you connect with other dogs who share DNA matches — kind of like 23andMe for dogs. It’s cute. Embark has a similar community feature. I haven’t used either extensively, but it’s a nice touch if you’re into that.
Price Comparison
- Embark Breed + Health: Usually $129–$199 depending on sales. I caught a sale for $149.
- Wisdom Panel Essential: Around $80–$100. Wisdom Panel Premium is closer to $150.
If budget is tight and you just want breed info, Wisdom Panel Essential does the job. But if you’re serious about health — and after losing Cooper, I am very serious about health — Embark is worth every extra dollar.
What I Wish I’d Done With Cooper
I never DNA tested Cooper. He was obviously a yellow Lab, so I figured there wasn’t much point. What I didn’t know was that DNA tests screen for health markers regardless of how “purebred” your dog is. Labs have known genetic predispositions to conditions like exercise-induced collapse, progressive retinal atrophy, and certain forms of myopathy. Would Embark have caught something that would have changed Cooper’s outcomes? I genuinely don’t know. But I know I’d feel better having tried.
My Verdict
If you’re going to buy one dog DNA test, buy Embark. The health panel is significantly more comprehensive at the standard tier, and that MDR1 finding on Birch alone made the entire investment worthwhile. Wisdom Panel is a good, cheaper option if you mostly want breed data and aren’t as focused on health screening.
But here’s the thing: knowing what’s in your dog’s genes doesn’t cause anxiety. It creates action. And after what I went through with Cooper, I’ll take actionable information over ignorance every single time.
Related reading: